Shopping center fight renewed

08/26/2010 12:00 AM |

Reeves Park residents refuse to say die when it comes to fighting plans for a shopping center at the northeast corner of Park Road and Sound Avenue.

They’ve hired an attorney who says the property should be considered zoned residential, which would bar a shopping center there.

Riverhead Town Supervisor Sean Walter disagrees, citing a court ruling from earlier this year that rejected the town’s 2004 rezoning of the property to residential use and deemed the application approved, subject to environmental review. The lawsuit was brought against the town by the property owner, EMB Enterprises, owned by Kenn Barra.

The supervisor hopes to convene a meeting with Mr. Barra and his attorney to discuss options, which Mr. Walter said could include the town’s acquiring the site.

“We might want to make it into a park,” he said in an interview.

EMB Enterprises bought the property for $1 million in July 2004.

Carolyn Zenk, an attorney hired by some Reeves Park residents, said in a letter to town officials last week that she believes the residential zoning on the property is valid, which would prohibit the commercial development.

Ms. Zenk, a former Southampton Town councilwoman who is also legal counsel for the Group for the East End, an environmental organization, said that while the courts had ruled in 2007 that the town had illegally rezoned the property to residential in 2004, the town later went back and rezoned the property legally in 2007. No court decision, she said, had any effect on that later zone change.

“Because the courts have invalidated the original zone change to a residential/agricultural use does not mean that your subsequent, properly enacted zone change to a residential/agricultural use is not valid,” Ms. Zenk wrote.

She argued that the town should not change the zoning back to commercial because the second rezoning was correct.

Mr. Walter disagreed. “I understand her position, but the appellate court decision says the site plan is approved, subject to SEQRA,” he said.

The supervisor said he believed the current zoning on the property is residential, but that it doesn’t apply to this project because of the court ruling.

“We can’t fight this any further,” Mr. Walter said of any effort to oppose the project. “We lost the lawsuit and the appellate court approved the site plan pending [environmental] review.”

Some Reeves Park residents say the project doesn’t belong in the rural residential area and fear it will clog their neighborhood with traffic.

“I feel with this development, plus the residential development set for the northwest side, the rural nature of Sound Avenue and the community of Reeves Park will change forever,” Eric Biegler, president of the Sound Park Heights Civic Association, wrote in a letter to residents. “If you think traffic is bad on our corner now, wait till this goes in… It is the beginning of the domino effect that will turn Sound Avenue into another Route 58,” he wrote.

EMB Enterprises intends to build three retail buildings and one 100-seat restaurant on the 4.1-acre property. The total square footage of the project would be about 28,000, with a 7,680-square-foot retail building that would be divided into four smaller stores; an 8,200-square-foot structure shown on the site plan as being one “dry store”; an 8,400-square-foot building, also divided into four smaller retail spaces; and a 3,800-square-foot restaurant.

Mr. Barra’s EMB Enterprises — he also owns East Wind Caterers — first proposed the retail and restaurant complex in 2003 for the northeast corner of Park Road and Sound Avenue, before actually purchasing the site. It was zoned for commercial use at the time. Soon after, Boom Development, a company headed by Southampton developer Ed Broidy, proposed another commercial development on the northwest corner of the same intersection, although Mr. Broidy has since discussed building houses on his land.

Facing opposition from the Reeves Park community, the Town Board in 2004 changed the zoning of both parcels — along with that of property on the south side of the intersection — from commercial to residential.

A lawsuit challenging the rezoning was filed by EMB Enterprises, and in 2007, a state Supreme Court judge sided with EMB.

The Town Board that year voted again to change the zoning to residential, intending to cover any technical problems that may have led to the ruling against the 2004 vote. At the same time, the town appealed the ruling, again under pressure from Reeves Park residents.

In February of this year, the state appellate division again backed EMB, saying the Town Board had rezoned their property improperly in 2004, and deeming the site plan approved, once it was subject to an environmental review under the state environmental quality review act, or SEQRA. “The town has no legal recourse,” Mr. Walter said in an interview this week. “We have to process this application.”

The last resort would be to ask the state’s highest court, the Court of Appeals, to review the case, but Mr. Walter said the town isn’t going to do that because there is no question of law at issue and the court would refuse to hear the case.

“The litigation is done,” he said. “The town would have been better off to negotiate with Mr. Barra while the lawsuit was still active and try to get some compromise.”

He said Mr. Barra had agreed to remove one of the 2,000-square-foot stores from the project.

“If the Reeves Park residents want to bring a lawsuit, they’re free to do so, but the appellate court decision is clear,” Mr. Walter said.

Mr. Barra could not be reached for comment.

tgannon@timesreview.com

30 Comment

  • Seriously helpful website post.Considerably thanks yet again. Retain producing.

  • i really like this religion. im an agnostic. but i believe if everyone was pastafarian it would be perhaps become a safer entire world significantly less wars a lot less things like that. but then we as human seings might uncover other issues to battle about. im only fifeteen. but i’ve a great grip of reality. i just hope you fellas are having fun. for the reason that you should reside your lives into the comprehensive now! yet what your carrying out to your entire world is awesome. keep it up!br /love aki!

  • it truly is much easier to understand the map and I’m able to now experience confident that I’m praying inside the proper direct in the direction of the kabah!

  • I submite my web site to that web-site although the result is, page creation fail

  • My 3 year outdated son took just one seem at this photo and stated, “look at that monkey flower.”

  • I’m the owner on the 68 Red 383 GTS referred to inside the two post which I’ve owned for 33 yrs. and whenever I take the car out I generally have a couple of wonderful complements or someone wants to glimpse it about whether or not in a stop light, gas station or merely managing down the road. Again while in the day I owned a 70 340 Swinger & my brother had a 69. Both have been 4 speeds with three:91 Certain Grip and they have been just one heck of a bang to the buck. They were sharp searching cars by using a wonderful performance reputation around the street or strip and heavily promoted by Grand Spaulding Dodge more than WLS radio in Chicago.

  • Terrific report. Brought back so many recollections.br /Asheville,NC had three tracks that we’re open 7 days a week.br /8 to 10 lanes and possess feature races all of the time.br /I use to really like going to all those tracks. I’d a Cox Controllerbr /and those would sometime catch fire. I had a red Manta Ray slot car.br /Remember it like it was yesterday. It had been about 1967 or so.br /Thanks for your good article and continue to keep on racin’

  • Maybe assemble in brute drive detection and connect it to some loud horns or anything to act as an alarm.

  • there isn’t any practical strategy to ignore a Kraken in one’s bathtub

  • Chicago Area. Applied TWP 1500 Cedartone Semi-transparent to the deck and fence in late winter/early spring. Deck was built in November & Fence in December. Both are built of pressure treated yellow pine. The treatment is AC2 micronized copper.br /First the great: I sprayed the fence after brushing off any dirt & offering it a spray-off and time to dry. I am really happy with it. I used to be hoping it might cover a bit far better but that’s the trade for the True semi-transparent. I see my wood-grain, knots… as it ought to be in my ebook as well as the color seems fantastic.br /The deck is about the north side of your property. 2/3′rds of it gets sunshine morning to all around noon, then shaded by large trees. The rest is extensive shade.br /To apply, I scrubbed it down extremely very well (twice) with an oxygen cleaner & rinsed multiple instances. Enable dry & applied by using a Deckmate brush/pad. It went on easily & looked terrific also, but only for just a couple months. Then the part that gets sunshine begun bleaching-out. Now some parts from the grain glimpse un-stained & others glimpse normal. Possibly I had a penetration issue, but I used to be hoping for significantly better protection from this high-end product.

  • I snagged that apple in advance of Dezflex, listened for the snake, construct the ship, survived the fish… But this mans brand is Steve, not Job. Really should I eliminate him in any event?

  • is a fellow named Bobby Patton tried to pass off this uber-rare muscle car because the true offer. Hemmings Auto Blog reports that not only was Patton called out by Chevelle Z16 enthusiasts, but for a result of his

  • Enjoyed each individual bit of your weblog posting.Considerably thanks yet again. Much obliged.

  • dear sir,br /really really practical. may possibly god reward your folks

  • Human Rights Commission’s get on it[Read]I talk ad nauseumer, in depth, with Selwyn Manning[Triangle]. [More Superior

  • !!! I am so excited to view this that despite your misgivings, I however will aided by the hope that some of your positive feedback will supply me with far more thoughts that I might like the leave unanswered. Thanks for this review, it has still left me intrigued.

  • ultimately someone stated it, how soon will obumer say it

  • Do i get to identify it soon after myself if I acquire it?

  • Romney Campaign observed dead on yacht, suicide not ruled out as coroner suspects hubris overdose, no signs of foul participate in as police carry on investgation…

  • Spot on, as constantly! Thanks for bringing a smile to our faces each and every day.

  • WOW these photos glance incredibly pleasant! I really hope the food items tastes as excellent as it looks in pics I will definitely test these recipes this weekend. Thanks for your fantastic report

  • Surely you can find a Kellison J system laying close to.

  • I agree , Mark. We had a person, not a smart move, the automatic transmission took a great deal electrical power to pull it the gas mileage was poor, poor good quality allover, etc. A person bumped in the rear bumper at the time and sort of twisted it, a system shop required to pull it off and straighten it for $75.00. Not becoming happy with that, I came dwelling, place on my leather gloves and straightened it BY HAND!!

  • depart it alone the way it stands, it doesnt really need to run. possibly a little bit “navel jelly” to stop the rust. do not restore it. at the similar stage in time I’d a 59 dodge suburban wagon painted inside of a quite related color scheme. the PB trans chirped 2nd gear. heady days my friends.

  • Enjoy the coat, the print is awesome :)

  • In case you imagine that is massive, you must see my….

  • Thank you, Shauna, on your put up. Blessings to you!

  • Effectively You may have To Go out At the time In Awile For more beer.Seriously That Garage Is usually a Perform Of Art….Amazing

  • sounds intresting which joke of the month is just cheesie

  • Sorry, Dave, but I can not locate any element of my article that contains language to ensure what you’re accusing me of.