Guest Column: The stories Mugs helped us tell
My wife, Leah, was over the moon when she found out a real coffee shop was opening in downtown Riverhead.
“Frankie, I know it’s not your thing, but come check it out with me,” she said.
I was never the type to sit at a cafe and sip a latte. A bar stool, maybe, but there are no sports games for me to watch at a coffee shop, and they don’t serve chicken wings.
However, I had to do it for Leah.
The first time we walked into Mugs on Main at 33 East Main St., we looked at each other and smiled from ear to ear. The long bar out front provided a place to rest and watch downtown.
The staff were kind and welcoming. They were proud to be part of bringing businesses back to downtown and truly took an interest in each person who placed an order.
It was the best of both worlds: the offerings of a high-end cafe and the feeling of a small town where everyone knew your name.
Co-owner Kasandra Watkins Schaeffer had a gift for making her coffee shop part of the Riverhead community. She provided space in the back room for artists, writers and musicians.\
I remember hearing about the open-mic night and deciding to participate. But I am far from a musician.
I became nervous as I listened to the talented performers. A young man named Kyle wrote songs with soul and played the acoustic guitar with passion and purpose.
For an instant I thought, “Will these songsmiths want to take a break from their lineup? Will they want to hear my story?”
Well, I was already there, and I wasn’t going home without reading.
When I walked to the front of the room and sat in the chair, I was honest.
“You all are so talented and made me realize how much I miss live music,” I said. “I’ve taken my spaceship to your planet, so I’m very interested in hearing your thoughts.”
I read a story about when I was 9 years old, riding my yellow BMX bike through the woods next to my father’s nursery.
Halfway through, I realized how quiet the room was. I could hear people breathing. I thought either the musicians were completely uninterested or I had captivated them and they were hanging on each word.
When I finished, there was an uneasy silence.
Then, suddenly, everyone in the room was clapping and saying how much they enjoyed the story. It was a breakthrough for me and one of the many wonderful times I had at Mugs on Main.
Kasandra did more than allow creative thinkers to use her back room. The cafe became a place for East End artists to bare their souls, play some strings and speak their written words.
Eventually, the musicians’ open mic faded, but Kasandra allowed me to hold a writers’ open mic. The third Thursday of the month became a magical time at 33 E. Main St. Published authors and newcomers came in for a beer, martini or espresso and to read their original stories.
The Well Spoken Writers Club is almost three years old now. We first met at Cutchogue New Suffolk Library, then moved to Mugs for a location that was more accessible to everyone. We have had five homes for our meetings, and I am grateful to all who gave us space.
In that back room, we read our original work, laughed, cried and offered heartfelt feedback. People who hardly knew each other bared their souls. Musicians were encouraged to play until their hearts were full.
Mugs on Main closed its doors Oct. 14, but the stories we shared there will live on.
Thank you, Kasandra. From the bottom of my heart, thank you.
Frank Petrignani is the founder of the Well Spoken Writers Club.

