Food and Drink

Cook This Now! Abigayle’s pork sausage wheel with tomato-fennel salad

Now and then, a new spot opens up on the East End that inspires you to pitch your simple supper at home and up the ante on your evening plans. That’s Abigayle’s — the newly opened restaurant from Patricia and James Mangiacapre, the couple behind South Jamesport’s beloved Watershed Kitchen & Inn. Housed inside the historic 1905 Preston House (formerly Myles on Main) at 428 E. Main St., Riverhead, this new destination is named after the couple’s pampered Yorkie, Abigayle. But don’t let the sweet namesake fool you: The space packs serious culinary and aesthetic drama across three floors.

The smartest move on date night is to start at the main floor’s stunning, warm-lit bar for a cocktail, then head downstairs to the newly opened basement speakeasy. Brooke Cantone and John Mazur of Jamesport’s Lumber + Salt handled the subterranean decor, with Cantone proving once again she’s a master at creating instant vibe. Throughout the space, she wove in subtle, whimsical nods to Abigayle the Yorkie—curating dog-themed vintage books, eclectic antiques and even a pair of upholstered “nun’s dog chairs” retrieved from a monastery in Brentwood. The resulting lounge blends seasoned salvage, vintage leather and cozy seating with a weekend DJ setup that dials up a high-energy feel. The sound system is intentionally tuned to promote real conversation (so no need to shout over your drink), making it feel less like a public venue and more like the best kind of exclusive, private living room party.

On the plate, chef Jorge Aparacio brings to life a menu that seamlessly weaves Patricia’s Dominican roots with James’ Italian family background. While there are plenty of elegant bistro options, James had to fight to get one particular childhood staple onto the final menu: a whole sausage wheel.

“I knew when we were opening this restaurant, I wanted shareable, family-style dishes,” James says. “That’s how it was in my house growing up—we’d share a meal. And there were always hot peppers on the table.”

Patricia agrees, noting that their shared goal is straightforward execution rooted in memory. “Both the Watershed and Abigayle’s resemble how we cook for each other,” she says. “It’s about bringing that approachable, homespun feel to the table with dishes that actually mean something to us.”

The dish is brilliant in its simplicity: a one-pound rope sausage stuffed with parsley and parmesan, seared to perfection, nestled next to a blistered long hot pepper, and topped with a bright salad of wedge-sliced heirloom tomatoes, razor-thin red onion, and shaved fennel. The secret ingredient that holds the whole dish together isn’t complicated seasoning—it’s a generous splash of quality red wine vinegar. As James points out, that acidity cuts right through the rich pork, lifting the entire plate from heavy to vibrant.

As we lean into cooler weather and indoor activities, the Mangiacapre’s Riverhead spot brings an easy yet cool, urban energy to your evening without needing to trek all the way into the city. But if you must stay in, this shareable sausage wheel is the ultimate centerpiece, bringing that same welcome-to-the-table atmosphere right to your own dining room. Don’t forget to dim all the lights.

Tips for the Home Cook

  • No BBQ Needed: You can easily achieve a rich, smoky char right on your stovetop using a heavy cast-iron grill pan, or in the oven using your broiler set to high (which acts like an upside-down grill).
  • Source Quality Rope Sausage: Stop by a local specialty butcher like Sonny’s Village Prime Meat Shoppe or Peconic Prime Meats in Southampton (sausage is a particular specialty of owner Steve Colabella). Look for a coiled pork sausage wheel stuffed with fresh parsley and Parmesan cheese. Secure it with two crossed wooden skewers before cooking so it holds its round shape when you flip it.
  • Char the Whole Pepper: Don’t slice your long hot pepper before cooking. Blister it whole right alongside the sausage until the skin is blackened in spots. Serving it intact alongside the meat gives the dish a rustic, high-impact visual presentation.
  • Don’t Skimp on the Vinegar: Red wine vinegar is the crucial counterweight to the pork’s rich fat. Toss your fresh tomatoes, razor-thin red onion and shaved fennel with a generous splash right before plating so the juices create a natural pan sauce on the plate.

Abigayle’s Pork Sausage Wheel with Tomato-Fennel Salad

Prep Time 15minutes minutes

Cook Time 15minutes minutes

Serves 4 servings

Ingredients

For the sausage:

  • 1 lb coiled pork sausage wheel (Parmesan and parsley stuffed)
  • 1 large green Italian long hot pepper, whole
  • 1 tbsp extra-virgin olive oil

For the salad:

  • 1 1/2 cups mixed heirloom tomatoes, cut into wedges (and halved cherry tomatoes)
  • 1/2 small red onion, sliced paper thin
  • 1/2 small fresh fennel pulp core removed and sliced paper thin
  • 2 tbsp extra-virgin olive oil
  • 1 1/2 tbsp high-quality red wine vinegar
  • 1 tbsp fresh chives, finely chopped
  • kosher salt and cracked black pepper to taste

Directions

Make the Salad: 

  • In a medium bowl, combine the wedge-sliced heirloom tomatoes, razor-thin red onion, and shaved fennel. Drizzle with 2 tablespoons of extra-virgin olive oil and 1 ½ tablespoons of red wine vinegar. Season with a pinch of kosher salt and cracked black pepper, toss gently, and set aside so the vegetables absorb the dressing.

Cook the Sausage and Pepper: 

  • Run two wooden skewers horizontally through the sausage wheel to lock it into shape, then rub both the sausage and whole long hot pepper with 1 tablespoon of olive oil.
  • Cast-Iron Grill Pan Method: Preheat a heavy cast-iron grill pan over high heat until smoking hot. Sear the sausage for 6 to 7 minutes per side until deeply charred and fully cooked through (internal temperature of 160°F). Sear the pepper alongside, turning frequently, until blistered and softened.
  • Broiler Method: Position your top oven rack 4 to 5 inches below the heating element and turn the broiler to high. Place the sausage wheel and pepper on a rimmed baking sheet. Broil for 5 to 6 minutes per side until deeply browned with charred edges and the pepper skin is blistered.
  • Transfer the seared sausage wheel to the center of a wide serving platter. Lay the blistered long hot pepper directly along the side. Mound the bright tomato-fennel salad high over the middle of the sausage wheel, letting the red wine vinaigrette pool around the bottom. Sprinkle with fresh chives and serve immediately, family-style.

Print Recipe


See more from southforker.com

Looking to comment on this article? Send us a letter to the editor instead.

Tags