Business

New owners take over beloved pizza spot on Riverhead waterfront

A longtime pizza joint on the Riverhead waterfront has changed hands — and its new owners plan to roll out changes to the menu and decor along with the dough.

Christopher Innace took over Roadhouse Brickoven Pizza, at 1111 West Main St., on Tuesday, Nov. 10, after buying the business from Stan Klasek.

Financial details of the deal were not disclosed.

The pizza business has been a big part of Mr. Innace’s life. He started as a dishwasher at 14 years old before buying his first pizzeria at 18.

“I had my own businesses including Innace Pizza, South Shore Pizza and Innace Frozen,” Mr. Innace told the Riverhead News-Review Friday. “I got into the frozen pizza business. We were supplying hotels, supermarkets and IGAs — we had about 650 accounts across Long Island and all five boroughs.”

Christopher Innace has returned to the pizza business as a co-owner of Riverhead’s Roadhouse Brickoven Pizza. (Credit: Nick Mongiovi)

He sold off his pizza businesses and worked in the precious metals industry for 34 years before returning to his first love.

Mishell Innace, who lives with her husband in Center Moriches, said he had long missed the pizzeria business.

“When we came out to take a look at the business itself, we fell in love with it,” Ms. Innace said. “It’s a destination place — it’s amazing.”

The purchase also brings Mr. Innace together with Lou Mondi, a childhood friend from William Floyd High School in Mastic Beach, who is now Roadhouse’s general manager.

Mr. Mondi has opened “numerous pizzeries across Long Island,” Ms. Innace said.

The Innaces plan interior updates at Roadhouse while keeping its familiar staff. (Credit: Nick Mongiovi)

“[Chris and Lou] always wanted to open a business together, so that’s what they did,” she said.

“It all came back full circle,” Mr. Innace added.

Roadhouse has been slinging pies for more than three decades. Mr. Klasek’s daughters Callie, 29, and Skyler, 27, will continue working behind the counter.

“We expect to maintain the Roadhouse tradition with continuity of the employees,” Ms. Innace said. “Having the same cooks, having the same pizza guy will help us continue to deliver whatever everybody is accustomed to, and with bringing in our own changes as far as dinners and things like that.”

Brian Tart, 63, of Rocky Point, was enjoying a slice Friday afternoon. He has been coming to Roadhouse on and off for years.

“If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it,” Mr. Tart said. “People come in all the time and they always come back because of the customer service and product.”

The couple hopes to build the restaurant’s catering business. Ms. Innace wants to introduce lunch specials and expand the dinner menu.

“Whatever we add on, it’s going to be our personal touch,” she said.

Inside, Ms. Innace loves the license plates on the walls but wants to change their display. She also wants to tone down the orangish wood and is considering different tiling to make cleaning easier.

The couple plans to hold a grand opening to showcase the changes, but a date has not been set.

“The community has been so welcoming already,” Ms. Innace said. “We transferred over the Facebook account on Tuesday night, and we made a post and got such a warm welcome from the community. It’s been really nice.”

Photos by Nick Mongiovi