Cuomo proposes new teacher rating system

Governor Cuomo giving his State of the State address the Empire State Plaza Convention Center in Albany Jan. 21. (Credit: Courtesy Flickr photo)
Governor Cuomo giving his State of the State address the Empire State Plaza Convention Center in Albany Jan. 21. (Credit: Courtesy Flickr photo)

During his annual State of the State address earlier this month, Gov. Andrew Cuomo outlined a 66-part presentation he dubbed New York’s “Opportunity Agenda.” 

Split into five separate platforms including justice, economic opportunity, education, public safety and government reform, Mr. Cuomo said singling out the agenda’s individual items — something he hasn’t done before — allows people to explore each concept more thoroughly.

“The State of the State is basically an announcement of policy themes that we’re going to pursue for that year,” he said. “We’ve dealt with many complex problems we’ve been trying to solve for a very long time. It takes time to understand what they are and really work your way through them.”

Whether state legislators agree with Mr. Cuomo’s solutions remains to be seen, since his proposals still have to pass through both houses in Albany.

We’ve picked out a few of those 66 “Opportunity Agenda” items on these pages. Take a look at the rest by going to

Mr. Cuomo proposed a new teacher rating system that would base 50 percent of an instructor’s evaluation on student test scores — an increase from 20 percent.

The governor said the change is needed because less than one percent of teachers were rated ineffective (the lowest category on the rating system) last year but students continued to “lag behind in performance.”

If the system were to go into effect, teachers would also need to achieve five consecutive years of effective ratings before being granted tenure, Mr. Cuomo said. Other proposals he discussed include passing the DREAM Act, increasing the state’s number of charter schools and expanding pre-K.

If the Legislature passes his education reforms, Mr. Cuomo said he’ll approve a 4.8 percent increase, or $1.1 billion, in school aid.

Although Riverhead Superintendent Nancy Carney agrees that assessments are a valuable way to measure student achievement, she described the state’s system as “unreliable.” She added that it lacks a plan for evaluating ESL (English as a second language) students and students with disabilities.

“Giving all students the same assessment regardless of their proficiency in the English language or on their developmental level yields a false picture of student achievement,” Ms. Carney said. “I am continually disappointed in the state for not recognizing this obvious problem in a ‘one-size fits all’ approach to student assessments.”

Mattituck-Cutchogue Superintendent Anne Smith said the district “takes assessments seriously and administers them with fidelity” and uses the results to help evaluate teacher performance and student academic growth.

Still, she said concerns over the state’s system are valid.

“Students are currently assessed as if they had been engaged with the current standards for several years,” Ms. Smith said. “It is simply too soon to use results of an assessment that is clearly under construction.”