ICE storms North Fork, allegedly arrests driver in line for ferry and two others in Greenport

Editor’s Note: This story was updated at 6:30 p.m. on Wednesday with the names of the arrested individuals.

Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents swept into Greenport early Wednesday, allegedly arresting three Hispanic men.

A witness told the Riverhead News-Review that ICE officers pulled up behind a car in line for the ferry around 6:30 a.m. and cuffed the driver.

Southold Police Chief Steve Grattan confirmed that federal agents “were out in Greenport this morning” — days after anti-ICE demonstrators held a vigil in the village to the protest the controversial activity.

Minerva Perez, executive director of OLA of Eastern Long Island, said the organization is currently working to find three members of the Greenport community who she said were scooped up in the ICE raid.

An OLA press alert sent Wednesday evening identified the three men as Alexandro Rivera Magaña, Martir Zambrano Diaz and Hugo Leonel Ardon Osorio.

“At this point we know they have no criminal background, have been here for 20+ years, and we have no idea of their whereabouts,” Ms. Perez wrote. “Most importantly, we need to bring these men home.”

It is unclear where the other two arrests took place.

Chief Grattan could not confirm if ICE rounded up any individuals.

The News-Review reached out to the Department of Homeland Security for comment.

Southold police were not informed that ICE agents would be coming “but while they were in Greenport, we were notified that they would be in the area,” Chief Grattan said.

Federal agents were also spotted near Greenport High School during the morning drop-off, according to multiple sources. The school district has a large Hispanic population.

“Our calm morning was interrupted by federal agents throughout the village at various locations,” said Greenport Mayor Kevin Stuessi. “I’ve spoken to the town supervisor and police chief about public safety concerns, and met with Superintendent Beth Doyle as well.”

Ms. Doyle was driving to a meeting in Patchogue when she raced back after being alerted of potential ICE activity near the high school. 

“Our kids are in the building safe right now; we are going to have kids stay in for lunch today as a precaution,” Ms. Doyle told the Riverhead News-Review. “I did send an email out to families, letting them know that the procedure if ICE does come to the school, they have to have a warrant, and we would consult our legal counsel.” 

Her administrative team received word of federal agents in Greenport at around 7:15 a.m., she said. Ms. Doyle confirmed school officials were outside during school drop-off this morning and did not report that there was ICE activity during student arrival. 

She shot down speculation that federal agents were at the Front Street campus after photos of a gray GMC Sierra pickup truck purportedly tied to ICE circulated on social media.

“That pickup truck is one of our employees’ who blocks one of the areas in the parking lot during drop-off, so people are not driving around kids unsafely,” Ms. Doyle said. “It was reported at like 7:02 a.m. and he was out there until about 7:20 or 7:30 a.m.” 

Two school resource officers were sent to the Greenport school, according to Southold Town Supervisor Al Krupski.

He said the public should still feel “absolutely” comfortable calling 911 in times of emergency. 

“That’s what we’re here for,” Mr. Krupski said.

There were no additional ICE sightings after the morning activity, according to Chief Grattan.

“We are very proud of our rapid responders for being on the scene in Greenport, and Shelter Island, and also driving up to witness some ice vehicles heading out of town west on 495,” Ms. Perez said. “This continues to be a travesty and the opposite of what our country should be standing for.”

The News-Review reached out to the Department of Homeland Security for comment.

Last week, Mr. Stuessi joined dozens of residents at a Southold Town Board meeting in calling on leaders to take a stand against allowing ICE activity on the North Fork.

Greenport’s Seth Egan presented a Change.org petition he had started that had been signed by 800 people. It had grown to more than 900 by Wednesday.

Southold officials hosted a public forum on immigration enforcement last January, where Chief Grattan said his officers would “not actively participate in immigration enforcement,” but would provide assistance in peacekeeping and traffic control upon request.

Chief Grattan said the town’s policy regarding immigration enforcement has not changed since last year’s meeting.

“Our priority is providing public safety to our community,” he said.

A vigil was held last Friday in Riverhead and eight other East End communities as part of a nationwide “ICE OUT” protest following the death of Alex Pretti in Minnesota. Mr. Pretti was shot and killed during a confrontation with federal agents.